Why My Child Can’t Let Go: Understanding the ADHD Need for “Why”

Why ADHD brains fixate on “why” and how kids and adults can move past uncertainty with practical strategies.

If you’ve ever watched a child with ADHD fixate on a fear or a question long after an event, you know it can be exhausting—and sometimes heart-wrenching. Recently, my six-year-old son gave me a front-row seat to this common ADHD challenge: the need to understand why.

The Summer Camp Incident

At summer camp, another child placed a toad on my son. What may have been an innocent, excited gesture for one child became terrifying for him. In his mind, the situation quickly escalated: “I could have died! Toads carry diseases!”

Even after validating his feelings and checking in with him repeatedly at home, he couldn’t let go. For three weeks, he replayed the event, trying to understand why it had happened. It wasn’t defiance or stubbornness—it was his ADHD brain seeking closure.

Why the “Why” Matters in ADHD

For many children (and adults) with ADHD, understanding why something happens is not just curiosity—it’s a neurological need. When faced with uncertainty, the ADHD brain can get stuck in an emotional loop, replaying scenarios over and over. Without answers, it’s hard to relax, focus, or move on.

In my son’s case, the unknown motivation of the other child became a source of hyperfocus. Until he could grasp the “why,” he struggled to be fully present in other moments.

How We Helped Him Move Forward

Here’s what made a difference:

Validation – We acknowledged his fear and discomfort. Naming his emotions helped him feel heard.
Agency – Instead of telling him what to do, we asked, “What kind of support do you need?” Giving him ownership empowered him to find a solution.
Structured problem-solving – He chose to have a conversation with the other child, with teachers supporting and facilitating the discussion to keep it safe.
Guided closure – By creating a structured space to explore the “why,” his brain could finally process the event and release the hyperfocus loop.

Tips for Parents of ADHD Kids

Recognize that the need to understand why is real and neurologically driven.
Hyperfixation on uncertainty isn’t stubbornness—it’s your child’s brain seeking emotional resolution.
Offer validation, give your child agency, and create structured opportunities to explore their questions.
Sometimes, adult guidance or facilitation is necessary to help them achieve closure safely.

Tips for Adults with ADHD

The need for why isn’t just a childhood challenge—it continues into adulthood. Here are some ways adults can manage hyperfocus on uncertainty:

Write it down – Journaling or note-taking can help process questions and fears without replaying them endlessly in your mind.
Set a “processing window” – Give yourself a defined time to explore the question or situation, then consciously shift to another task.
Talk it out – Sharing with a trusted friend, partner, or therapist can provide perspective and help resolve lingering questions.
Break the “why” into smaller questions – Instead of tackling a massive unknown, focus on specific pieces you can understand or act on.
Ground your body – Movement, deep breathing, or other grounding techniques can reduce emotional intensity and allow your mind to step back.
Accept some uncertainty – ADHD brains crave closure, but not every question has an immediate answer. Learning to tolerate ambiguity is key.

Understanding the ADHD need for “why” changes how we respond—to ourselves and others. Instead of forcing our brains or our children to move on, we can provide tools, guidance, and safe spaces to find answers and finally let go.

📥 Curious if You Might Have ADHD?

If this blog resonates and you’ve ever wondered “Could I have ADHD?” — I created a FREE ADHD Screening Toolkit to help you explore that question. It includes self-assessment tools and guidance on what to do next.

👉 Access the FREE ADHD Screening Toolkit here!

💌 Want More Support Like This?
If you found this helpful, I send out occasional emails with more posts like this, upcoming workshops, and new resources for ADHDers, self-healers, and helpers.

👉 Join the email list here to stay in the loop.

Home